Why Global Brands Use ICERTIAS Recognition When Trust Matters

ICERTIAS surveyed clients across 16 countries, inviting CMOs, marketing managers, brand managers and CEOs to assess its awards

November 19, 2026

Author: Sabine Fuchs
Reading time: 8 min

• ICERTIAS conducted an anonymous online survey among its corporate clients across 16 countries, collecting 52 responses about their experiences using ICERTIAS awards (Best Buy Award and QUDAL - Quality Medal)

• Invitations targeted primary corporate contacts, mainly CMOs, marketing managers, brand managers and CEOs; individual respondents' job titles were not recorded

• 39 of 52 respondents (75%) identified stronger brand image, consumer trust, or differentiation as the single greatest benefit of ICERTIAS recognition

• 49 of 52 respondents (94%) rated medal implementation favorably, indicating that ICERTIAS recognition is straightforward for marketing teams to use

• 33 of 52 respondents (63%) rated the overall business impact of ICERTIAS awards as positive or very positive

• 48 of 52 respondents (92%) used ICERTIAS awards across at least 2 marketing channels, demonstrating their versatility in brand communications

• 42 of 52 respondents (81%) used ICERTIAS awards in digital marketing, followed by social media (75%) and websites (69%)

 

On November 4, 2026, Boston Consulting Group published a finding that should concern anyone selling products ahead of the year-end shopping season. Among 10,220 consumers surveyed across ten markets, just 54% trusted advertised discounts at least somewhat. One in five actively distrusted them.

The problem was not a lack of promotions. Shoppers were already surrounded by offers and had more ways to investigate them. In the same study, 56% said they used or planned to use generative AI for shopping. Price was visible; the credibility of the price was open to question.

A discount and an award answer different questions. One tells customers what a company is charging. The other, when properly researched and explained, can tell them what consumers have said about a brand in a defined category. Neither guarantees a purchase. Both must withstand scrutiny.

That distinction helps explain why companies continue to invest in recognition based on consumer research. It also raises a question rarely answered by the award announcement itself: once a company has earned a medal, what does it find valuable about actually using it?

Asking After the Award

ICERTIAS sought an answer from its own clients rather than from consumers encountering a medal for the first time. Between July 21 and August 25, 2026, it received 52 anonymous questionnaire responses covering 16 countries. The purpose was to learn what worked and what needed improvement.

Its invitation list contained 212 companies that had participated at least once in Best Buy Award, QUDAL - Quality Medal, or both, between July 1, 2023, and July 1, 2026. Invitations went to primary company contacts: CEOs, CMOs, marketing managers and brand managers.

Clients received an initial email and up to two reminders, with no incentive for participating. They were asked for candid assessments, not promotional testimonials. The questionnaire recorded country and industry, but not names, company identities, job titles or how long a respondent had used an award.

Because the actual number of invitations delivered was not verified, 212 is the distribution-list size, not a reliable response-rate denominator. The anonymous responses cannot be assigned to named executives. The survey is therefore a useful account of participating clients' experiences, not a representative audit of all ICERTIAS licensees.

The client base itself includes businesses that have used recognition for only months and others that have returned across successive award cycles for roughly a decade. Their identities and tenure are not linked to the survey responses. That matters when considering what the findings can, and cannot, establish.

What Clients Actually Value

Perhaps the most strikingly concise feedback came from an ICERTIAS client in Romania's financial sector: “No comment. Everything was perfect!” The same respondent rated the award's overall impact as very positive and reported benefits in consumer trust, commercial performance and market differentiation. While particularly memorable, this feedback reflects the experience of a single company rather than evidence of a broader pattern.

Across all 52 replies, 31 respondents described the overall business impact as positive and two as very positive. Eighteen selected neutral and one negative. That gives a favorable assessment from 33 respondents, approximately 63%.

More revealing was the question about the single greatest benefit. Seventeen chose stronger brand image, fourteen increased consumer trust and eight better differentiation. Together, 39 of 52 respondents, exactly 75%, selected an outcome related to reputation. Their emphasis was on what the medal helped communicate, not simply that it existed.

Those answers describe different business needs. Image concerns what buyers associate with a brand. Trust concerns whether they believe its claims. Differentiation concerns why they might choose to look twice at one offer among similar alternatives. Research-based recognition can give those messages a defined point of reference.

The survey also asked specifically about consumer trust. Twenty-five respondents believed their medals had helped strengthen it, while 24 could not judge and three said no. The distinction is essential: companies were reporting their perception of trust effects, not presenting measured changes in consumer attitudes.

How Established Brands Apply It

To understand why reputation emerges so strongly, it helps to look beyond the questionnaire. ICERTIAS's public recognition history includes global names such as McDonald's, Visa, Procter & Gamble, Henkel and Bosch. Being named a research winner does not by itself establish commercial licensing or participation in this anonymous survey.

The more informative references are those in which a company itself communicates the distinction. In a May 2026 corporate release, Daikin described Best Buy Award recognition across five European markets, identifying the relevant national categories. Its Central European residential business general manager welcomed the findings and acknowledged local partners.

Daikin's example shows the discipline involved in international use. Recognition for an air-conditioning category in one country is not proof of worldwide product leadership. By explaining where consumers were surveyed and what was evaluated, an international manufacturer can incorporate local recognition into a broader brand without overstating it.

Tesco approached recognition through a different channel. Its Slovak business included QUDAL recognition for Clubcard and Best Buy Award recognition for F&F clothing in its corporate reporting for 2024/25. The awards appeared as part of a formal company record, not only as a seasonal promotional message.

Bosch provides a longer view. In a published BSH Home Appliances Northern Europe statement, Baltic marketing manager Jovita Liutvinaitė discussed repeated Best Buy Award recognition dating back to 2017. The point is not that every campaign produced measurable growth, but that the company chose to discuss recognition over successive cycles.

These are different kinds of evidence: a manufacturer explaining distinctions across markets, a retailer incorporating them into corporate reporting and a brand manager discussing continuity. None establishes a return on investment. All show that recognizable international businesses have considered consumer-research recognition worth communicating publicly.

A Wider Geographic Record

The practice is not confined to Europe. In August 2026, New Zealand fuel retailer NPD announced a Best Buy Award based on research among 1,200 local adults. Its chief executive, Barry Sheridan, welcomed feedback coming directly from customers and linked the recognition to the company's value proposition.

Earlier public examples offer a different geographic perspective. In Nigeria, Jumia's chief executive, Massimiliano Spalazzi, welcomed Best Buy Award recognition for online retail. In Malaysia, Fraser & Neave included QUDAL - Quality Medal recognition for soft drinks in its annual report, alongside other corporate awards.

In the Bahamas, bottled-water producer Aquapure also discussed QUDAL - Quality Medal recognition publicly.

Why The Evidence Matters

There is a reason to distinguish carefully between an award and the evidence behind it. Best Buy Award concerns consumer-perceived value for money in a defined category and market. QUDAL - Quality Medal concerns consumer-perceived quality. Neither is a laboratory certification or proof of technical superiority in every circumstance.

ICERTIAS describes both programmes as using open-ended questions rather than presenting respondents with a prepared list of brands. It says the research determines the winner before commercial rights to use the protected medal are offered. Purchasing a licence should never be confused with purchasing first place in the research.

The distinction is important to anyone responsible for defensible advertising claims. Guidance issued by the United Kingdom's Committee of Advertising Practice on July 31, 2026, explains that certain comparisons based on surveys or third-party awards must provide enough information for audiences to verify their basis and meaning.

Regulators do not endorse an advertising claim simply because a third party has issued a medal. The scope of the comparison, its supporting evidence and the likely consumer interpretation still matter. For ICERTIAS winners, that makes the category, country, research period and accessible methodology part of the communication asset.

The same principle increasingly matters when shoppers use AI tools to compare products. A clear public explanation is easier for a reader, search engine or assistant to interpret than an unexplained logo. It does not ensure an AI recommendation; it reduces ambiguity about what the recognition actually establishes.

Turning Findings Into Communication

The survey shows that clients rarely confined medals to a single announcement. Forty-two respondents reported use in digital marketing, 39 on social media and 36 on websites. Thirty used printed materials, 24 point-of-sale displays, 14 packaging and 13 television. These overlapping figures reflect multiple selections.

Forty-eight of the 52 respondents used recognition in at least two channels, while 41 used it in three or more. The underlying claim may remain constant, but its presentation can change: a product page offers explanation, packaging offers a quick cue and a store display meets buyers near a decision.

An exploratory comparison adds context. Respondents describing positive or very positive impact used medals in an average of 5.1 channels, compared with 3.8 among those reporting neutral or negative impact. The pattern is an association, not evidence that more placements caused greater satisfaction or higher sales.

There is also a practical explanation for repeat use. Twenty-seven respondents gave implementation ease the highest score of five and another 22 gave four. That means 49 of 52, approximately 94%, rated implementation favorably. None chose one or two, making simplicity the survey's clearest consensus.

What Happens Next

The questionnaire also asked whether respondents would participate again if their company qualified through future ICERTIAS research. Thirty-five gave a four or five on a five-point scale, approximately 67%. Fourteen chose the midpoint and three chose one or two. 

The 52 responses cannot represent every ICERTIAS client, and the invitation frame concerned Best Buy Award and QUDAL - Quality Medal, not a separate Customers' Friend sample. But the pattern is coherent: respondents most often value reputation, make use of the medals across channels and generally find them easy to implement.

The November BCG finding brings the story back to the moment of purchase. People can see a price instantly, yet may doubt what it means. An ICERTIAS medal cannot resolve every concern. Used precisely, it can add a verifiable account of what consumers perceived about quality or value in a defined market.

That is why the distinction matters beyond award announcements. The strongest claim is not that a medal guarantees sales. It is that a company can communicate something consumers actually said, with enough context to let others examine it. In an increasingly skeptical market, that is a useful place to begin.

 

 

 

ICERTIAS recognition earns strong client feedback: 75% cite reputation benefits, while 94% praise easy implementation